Are Scratch and Dent Appliances Worth the Savings?

Last Updated: October 22, 2026

Table of Contents

• What Scratch and Dent Appliances Actually Are
  • Cosmetic Damage vs. Functional Damage
• How Much Do You Really Save on Scratch and Dent Appliances?
  • The Total-Cost Math Most Buyers Skip
  • A Simple Cost Worksheet
• Pros and Cons of Buying Scratch and Dent
• What to Check When Buying Scratch and Dent Appliances
  • Inspection Checklist by Appliance Type
• Scratch and Dent Appliance Warranty: What's Covered and What Isn't
  • The Four Warranty Terms That Decide Coverage
  • How Return Windows Interact With Warranty Coverage
• Scratch and Dent Appliance Return Policy: Read This Before You Pay
• A Decision Framework: Damage Location, Discount Size, and Long-Term Costs
• Frequently Asked Questions

What Scratch and Dent Appliances Actually Are

Scratch and dent appliances are brand-new, fully functional machines that carry cosmetic damage, usually a ding, scuff, or dent on a side panel. They are not used, refurbished, or floor models, though retailers sometimes display them side by side.

That distinction matters more than any single discount figure. A scratch-and-dent refrigerator that cools correctly is a working refrigerator. The only question is whether the blemish bothers you and whether the price reflects it.

Cosmetic Damage vs. Functional Damage

Cosmetic damage affects appearance only: scratches, dings, paint chips, and dents on panels that do not house controls or compressors. Functional damage affects how the machine runs, and it is not what the scratch-and-dent label is supposed to describe.

A common mistake is assuming every markdown hides a mechanical problem. It usually does not. What you should verify is that the damage is documented and confined to the exterior.

How Much Do You Really Save on Scratch and Dent Appliances?

Savings on scratch and dent appliances typically land between 10% and 50% off retail, according to retailer guidance from Appliance Solutions' buying guide, with the discount scaling with damage severity and location.

The percentage off is not the number that matters. The number that matters is what you pay after delivery, installation, haul-away, and any repair. Most buyers compare the sticker price to the retail price and stop there.

The Total-Cost Math Most Buyers Skip

A true total-cost comparison includes every line item that appears on the final receipt, not just the shelf tag. The categories below are the ones that most often turn a 40% markdown into a 15% markdown once the paperwork is done.

• Delivery fees. Sellers commonly charge a flat delivery fee that scales with distance and whether the unit requires a lift gate or stair carry. A fee quoted for a standard curbside drop can double when the appliance must be brought inside and up a flight of stairs.
• Installation charges. Dishwashers, ranges, over-the-range microwaves, and built-in refrigerators often require a licensed installer to connect water, gas, or hardwired electrical. Installation is frequently priced separately from delivery, and some sellers will not deliver without scheduling installation at the same time.
• Haul-away of your old appliance. Removing the old unit is a separate service at many retailers. If haul-away is not included, you either pay a fee or arrange disposal yourself, which in many municipalities means a bulky-item pickup fee.

A Simple Cost Worksheet

Before you commit, write down these six numbers side by side for the scratch-and-dent unit and for the comparable new retail unit:

1. Sticker price after discount
2. Delivery fee
3. Installation charge
4. Haul-away fee
5. Parts or trim replacement cost
6. Protection plan cost, if any

Add lines 1 through 6 for each unit. The difference between the two totals is your real savings, and it is almost always smaller than the percentage on the tag. If the real savings do not clear your threshold after fees, the discount is not a discount.

Pros and Cons of Buying Scratch and Dent

The case for buying is straightforward: you get a new appliance with full functionality at a lower price, and the damage is often on a surface nobody sees after installation. The case against is equally real, and it comes down to warranty terms, return restrictions, and resale value.

Pros:

• Lower purchase price on a new, unused machine
• Damage is frequently cosmetic and out of sight
• Same brand and model as the retail version

Cons:

• Manufacturer warranty may be reduced or voided
• Return and exchange windows are often shorter
• Damage can worsen if it sits on a structural seam

What to Check When Buying Scratch and Dent Appliances

What to check when buying scratch and dent appliances comes down to three things: where the damage sits, whether the machine runs, and what paperwork you leave with. Inspect the unit yourself, run it if the seller allows, and get the damage and warranty terms in writing before you pay.

Inspection Checklist by Appliance Type

Use this checklist on the floor or at delivery:

Get Started Today →

• Refrigerators: Check door alignment, gasket seal, and that the dent is not on the door face. Confirm it cools before it leaves the warehouse.
• Washers: Look for dents near the drum housing. Run a spin cycle if possible and listen for vibration.
• Dryers: Inspect the door latch and lint housing. Confirm the drum turns freely.

Scratch and Dent Appliance Warranty: What's Covered and What Isn't

A scratch and dent appliance warranty usually covers mechanical and electrical failure but excludes cosmetic damage. That split is the single most important term to confirm in writing. The manufacturer's warranty generally follows the machine, not the blemish, but some sellers sell units with a reduced or third-party warranty instead. Treat warranty coverage as a set of fine-print mechanics, not a yes-or-no answer.

The Four Warranty Terms That Decide Coverage

Most warranty disputes on scratch-and-dent units come down to four terms. Read each one before you pay.

• Who honors the warranty. The manufacturer, the retailer, or a third-party administrator can each be the obligor. A manufacturer warranty is generally the strongest because it is backed by the brand and honored through authorized service networks. A retailer-backed warranty depends on the retailer staying in business and on its service network. A third-party plan is only as good as its administrator's reputation and claims process.
• Exclusions for pre-existing damage. Many warranties exclude damage that existed at the time of sale. Because scratch-and-dent units are sold with disclosed damage, the seller may argue that a later functional failure stems from that same damage. Get the disclosed damage described in writing and confirm that the warranty does not treat it as a pre-existing exclusion.
• Cosmetic vs. functional coverage. Cosmetic damage is almost always excluded. The question is whether a cosmetic defect that later causes a functional failure, a dented door that misaligns a seal, for example, is covered. Ask the seller to state in writing whether consequential damage from a disclosed cosmetic defect is covered or excluded.

How Return Windows Interact With Warranty Coverage

A warranty and a return window are different protections, and the return window is often the shorter of the two. A typical return window is measured in days, while a warranty is measured in months or years.

Confirm these points in writing before you pay:

• The return window in days and whether it starts at purchase or delivery
• Whether cosmetic damage disqualifies a return
• Who pays return shipping or haul-away

The Federal Trade Commission's guidance on warranties explains the difference between full and limited warranties, which is the language you will see on the card in the box.

Scratch and Dent Appliance Return Policy: Read This Before You Pay

A scratch and dent appliance return policy is typically stricter than a standard retail return policy. Many sellers treat cosmetic damage as disclosed and final sale, and some charge a restocking fee or refuse returns on units marked down past a certain threshold.

Confirm these points in writing:

• The return window in days
• Whether cosmetic damage disqualifies a return
• Who pays return shipping or haul-away

A Decision Framework: Damage Location, Discount Size, and Long-Term Costs

Use this framework to make the call quickly.

Long-term costs swing the decision. A unit with a compromised door seal can raise energy use over time, and replacement parts for cosmetic trim are often not covered.

Buying scratch and dent appliances works best when you can see the condition, confirm the warranty, and get delivery and installation priced up front.